How NOT to use AI Tools for Education and Learning

Artificial Intelligence has quickly woven itself into the fabric of our daily lives and sparked debates about its ethical implications. One of the most intriguing—and contentious—areas of its influence is education. As AI tools like ChatGPT become increasingly accessible, questions arise about their role in helping or hindering the learning process. Should we embrace these tools as transformative educational aids, or are they simply shortcuts that could lead to intellectual stagnation?

In this post, I look at an example of bad AI use and explore both the promise and pitfalls of using AI in education, and how to strike a balance between leveraging these tools and fostering true learning.

Example: Bad Use of AI by Students

A recent discussion on Reddit [link] highlighted a case where an elementary school student used ChatGPT to complete homework assignments. While the use of AI by students isn’t entirely new at this point in 2025 (college and high school students are known to be employing these tools), the fact that even younger children are adopting them raises important questions. For instance, will reliance on AI prevent children from truly learning?

Humans have always sought ways to simplify tasks, from the invention of the wheel to the development of electricity. In many ways, AI is the next frontier of human innovation, reducing the effort required to solve problems. But when applied to education, the implications become far more complex. At its core, education is not just about producing answers—it’s about understanding and internalizing the processes that lead to those answers.

A Universal Human Trait: Finding the Easier Path

History has shown that humans are naturally inclined to find shortcuts. From the invention of the printing press to the advent of modern computers, technological advancements have often centered on reducing labor—both physical and intellectual. AI, however, might represent a turning point in this pattern. It is not merely a tool to reduce effort; it has the potential to eliminate effort entirely in certain contexts.

Consider this: A student is asked to solve a math problem. Instead of working through the equations, they use ChatGPT to instantly produce the correct answer. The time saved may seem beneficial, but the process of learning—understanding how to break down and solve the problem—is skipped entirely. This trend has significant implications not just for individual learners but for society as a whole.

Why Over-Reliance on AI is Problematic

Let’s go back to this scenario where a child uses AI to complete all their math homework. They input the problem, receive the answer, and copy it down without further thought. While this may seem efficient, the child isn’t engaging with the material, nor are they developing critical problem-solving skills. Their brain becomes a mere conduit, passing information from the AI to the worksheet without truly absorbing it.

The danger here isn’t just a lack of learning—it’s the potential for a generation to become overly dependent on AI. If these tools are no longer available, such as during a technical failure, students who haven’t developed the ability to think independently may find themselves at a significant disadvantage.

Moreover, this dependency raises a philosophical question: What role does the human mind play when AI is doing the heavy lifting? If we delegate all intellectual labor to AI, we risk losing not just skills but also the ability to contextualize and apply knowledge in meaningful ways.

AI’s Role in Education: A Prediction

Despite these concerns, AI is bound to become a central component of education at both institutional and individual levels. Schools are already experimenting with AI-driven curriculums. For example, a charter school in Arizona has developed a program centered around AI tools. This trend is likely to grow, though its adoption will vary by region and socio-economic factors.

Unfortunately, this shift could deepen existing inequalities. A fully human-led education—free of AI involvement—might become a luxury afforded only to those with greater financial means. For many, AI-assisted learning may become the norm. This potential divide highlights the importance of intentional, equitable integration of AI into educational systems.

The Double-Edged Sword of AI Tools

It’s important to recognize the inherent duality of AI’s role in education. On one hand, AI has the capacity to make learning more efficient and personalized. It can provide immediate feedback, adapt to individual learning styles, and open doors to resources that might otherwise be inaccessible. For example, I’d be surprised if language learning platforms like Duolingo and academic resources like Coursera aren’t already investigating how to leverage AI to enhance their offerings.

On the other hand, the misuse of AI threatens to undermine the learning process entirely. Tools designed to support education can quickly become crutches that replace genuine engagement with the material. The challenge lies in finding ways to use AI responsibly, ensuring that it augments rather than replaces traditional learning methods.

Using AI the Right Way: A Learning Companion, Not a Crutch

AI doesn’t have to be the villain in this narrative. When used thoughtfully, it can enhance the learning process rather than replace it. Here are some examples of how AI can be a valuable educational tool:

1. Personalized Study Guides: Students can use AI to generate outlines of key topics they need to master. For instance, asking ChatGPT to summarize a chapter or prepare a list of important concepts can provide a helpful starting point for independent study.
2. Interactive Quizzes: AI tools can act like virtual flashcards, testing students on various subjects and providing immediate feedback.
3. Accessible Expertise: Want to learn about history but don’t have an expert at your beckon call? AI can offer a wealth of knowledge at your fingertips, enabling you to ask questions and explore topics in depth.

These examples demonstrate how AI can serve as a “study buddy,” empowering students to engage more deeply with their material. The key is to ensure that AI is used to supplement the learning process, not shortcut it.

Potential Countermeasures for Educational Integrity

As AI inevitably becomes more widely utilized in education, institutions will need to adapt. This could mean rethinking how tests are administered—perhaps returning to handwritten exams or oral presentations to ensure students truly understand the material. Alternatively, educators might focus on fostering higher-order thinking skills that AI cannot easily replicate, such as critical analysis, creativity, and emotional intelligence.

Additionally, the rise of AI in education calls for robust ethical guidelines. Schools and policymakers must establish boundaries that encourage responsible use while discouraging misuse. For example, integrating AI literacy into curriculums could help students understand both the benefits and limitations of these tools, fostering a healthier relationship with technology.

The Road Ahead

The integration of AI in education is inevitable, but its long-term impact will depend on how it’s implemented. For individuals, the challenge will be to resist the temptation of easy answers and embrace the work of learning. Those who can strike this balance—leveraging AI to enhance their understanding while maintaining their intellectual independence—will have a significant advantage in the future.

For educators and institutions, the focus should be on creating environments that prioritize meaningful learning experiences. This includes not only embracing AI’s potential but also addressing its pitfalls. By fostering critical thinking, creativity, and adaptability, we can prepare students for a world where AI is a useful tool rather than a replacement for human intellect.

[mailerlite_form form_id=3]